GST on Development Agreements: Bombay High Court Offers Major Relief to Real Estate Developers

Judgment Date: April 8, 2025

Case: Shrinivasa Realcon Pvt. Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner, CGST

Court: Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench

Judges: Justice Avinash G. Gharote & Justice Abhay J. Mantri

Overview of the Case

Shrinivasa Realcon Pvt. Ltd. entered into a development agreement on April 7, 2022, with a landowner in Nagpur. The agreement allowed the company to construct a multi-storey complex on an 8,000 sq. ft. plot. As part of the deal, the developer received ₹7 crores and two apartments.

Later, the GST department issued a demand notice and a show cause notice. The officials claimed GST was applicable under Entry 5B of the 2017 GST Notification, as amended in 2019. Their argument was that the development rights granted fell within the definition of taxable services.

Legal Question Raised

The key question before the court was:

Can GST be applied under Entry 5B when a developer uses only the owner’s existing rights and does not acquire additional TDR (Transfer of Development Rights) or FSI (Floor Space Index)?

Court’s Detailed Analysis

1. No Third-Party TDR or FSI Involved

The agreement only allowed the use of the land’s existing development rights. Neither the landowner nor the developer acquired any additional FSI or TDR from a third party.

2. What Entry 5B Actually Covers

Entry 5B is applicable only when a person transfers development rights or FSI to a promoter, which is treated as a taxable service. The Court clarified that this clause relates specifically to third-party transfers—not internal development permissions.

3. Definition of TDR Under Planning Laws

The Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations (UDCPR) define TDR as additional development rights granted as compensation. Since no such transaction occurred here, Entry 5B was deemed irrelevant.

4. Clause 18 Misinterpreted by the GST Authority

The GST department cited a clause that mentioned execution of apartment deeds under the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act. However, the Court held this clause did not relate to any supply of services or rights that fall under the GST ambit.

✅ Final Judgment

The High Court ruled in favor of Shrinivasa Realcon Pvt. Ltd., stating:

• The development agreement does not fall under Entry 5B
• No taxable TDR or FSI transaction occurred
• Both the show cause notice and demand order were invalid
• GST authorities had no grounds to levy tax on this agreement

🔍 Why This Case Matters to Real Estate Professionals

This judgment provides vital clarity:

• Development agreements that do not involve external purchase of TDR/FSI are not taxable under Entry 5B.
• Builders can rely on this precedent to challenge unwarranted GST demands.
• The decision encourages fair taxation and supports transparent development models.

Important Legal References

• Entry 5B, Notification No. 11/2017 – Central Tax (Rate), amended 29.03.2019
• Clause 11.2 of the UDCPR, Maharashtra
• Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act, 1970

Conclusion

The Bombay High Court’s judgment in this case is a landmark ruling that reinforces the boundaries of GST applicability in real estate transactions. It clearly distinguishes between internal development permissions and third-party TDR/FSI transfers, setting a fair and logical standard for future tax assessments.

For developers and legal professionals, this case serves as a powerful precedent to protect legitimate development models from unnecessary GST burdens. Understanding the scope of Entry 5B is no longer optional—it’s essential for risk-free project planning in India’s evolving real estate sector.

LinkedIn Link : RMPS Profile

This article is only a knowledge-sharing initiative and is based on the Relevant Provisions as applicable and as per the information existing at the time of the preparation. In no event, RMPS & Co. or the Author or any other persons be liable for any direct and indirect result from this Article or any inadvertent omission of the provisions, update, etc if any.

Please follow and like us:

RMPSCo.